2022年9月30日 星期五

Thoughts on Marvel's She-Hulk: Attorney at Law


"Utter shit!"  

"This show is terrible!"  

"Marvel is going downhill!"  

Etc., etc., etc.

Is that what I'm expected to say?

The thing is, I kind of like She-Hulk: Attorney at Law.  I watched episode 7 last night and while yes, this show has problems, it's not that bad.

I have to be real here and say I haven't seen all of the Marvel shows.  I watched the Netflix series up to The Defenders.  I watched bits of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.  I tried and failed with Agent Carter and The Inhumans.  I didn't bother with Runaways, Cloak and Dagger and Helstrom.  I probably won't bother with Adventure Into Fear either.

As far as the Marvel Studios shows go, I enjoyed Wandavision the most.  I thought the ending of that show was weak, but it was a good setup for Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness, which should have, in my opinion, featured Scarlet Witch instead of Doctor Strange.

I couldn't get into The Falcon and the Winter Soldier and Moon Knight.  I still think Loki is terrible.  Hawkeye bored me, and I've only seen parts of What If...?  I might see Ms. Marvel, but then again I might not.  I loved the comic book series, and I'm worried the show will ruin my memories of the comic.

And She-Hulk?  I grew up reading those comics, but I haven't read any of them since I was little.  I was fascinated by the Hulk, and those She-Hulk comics were often a nice sidestep into other aspects of an evolving process of hulkification.

(Whatever that means.)


But yeah, I kind of like She-Hulk.  It's very dumb, but for all its dumbness it's entertaining.  Tatiana Maslany is a great actress, and despite plot holes and other problems with the writing she remains convincing as both Jennifer Walters and She-Hulk.  Is the CGI in the show awesome?  NOPE, but I will say that the CGI in episode 7 looks better, and that moment where Jennifer is at Blonsky's retreat struggling with the dichotomy between Jen and She-Hulk really sold the character for me.

No, I don't know why she didn't just turn into She-Hulk, jump a few miles away and get better cellphone service, and no, I don't know why her car getting smashed was such a monumental problem, but that moment in the group made the show very relatable, and it's a better moment than the best moments in many other Marvel shows.

Which is not to say that the pacing in this show isn't an issue.  Whoever's writing the scripts seems to be in a godawful rush to get to each episode's conclusion, almost as if they either didn't know how to reach that conclusion or they didn't want to be writing the script in the first place.  The actors involved are game enough, and the rom-com vibe could have worked, but this show really needs to slow down.  That big, season-ending conclusion needs to be earned.

I just hope they tap the brakes for the last two episodes.  No need to have some world-ending villain appear out of nowhere.  She-Hulk's struggle can remain a personal one, and bringing in some ridiculous bad guy so close to the end of the series will probably do more harm than good.

For what it's worth I'd like to see more of She-Hulk in a feature film.  With better CGI Tatiana Maslany can easily carry the role, and this is one instance where a character's diversity really will make a cinematic universe both more inclusive and more interesting.


Related Entries:


Fun Fact 1: They wanted to include She-Hulk in The Death of the Incredible Hulk TV movie, way back in 1990.

Fun Fact 2: Later still New World Pictures planned on making a She-Hulk movie, with Brigitte Nielsen as Jennifer Walters/She-Hulk.  There are photos here.

Sad Reflection: And what about Marvel's other (more) interesting female superheroine?  What about Spider-Woman?  You'd think Sony would make a Spider-Woman film a priority, but no, no plans for Jessica Drew as yet.  Maybe they're doing us a favor?

Update: After writing this I watched the first episode of Ms. Marvel and the first three episodes of the Netflix Punisher series.  Ms. Marvel lost me at the end of the first episode, while that extended torture/interrogation scene in Punisher just started to seem ridiculous.  I'll definitely watch the remaining two episodes of She-Hulk, but I'm not sure about Ms. Marvel and Punisher.

2022年9月27日 星期二

Zero Fail by Carol Leonnig (2021)


"'It is frustrating to me to see a job I truly loved and people I worked closely with being so poorly managed and led."

Recent news regarding the Secret Service?  I only know what I hear from my mom, who regards Donald Trump in pretty much the same way the Ayatollah Khamenei regards The West.  Get her started on Trump, the Secret Service and insurrections, and before you know it you'll be forced into a detour of Everything Wrong With America.

I walked into this book knowing very little about the U.S. Secret Service.  I knew they'd been "implicated" in various things, but that was about it.  I also, like most other people, have seen movies like JFK and In the Line of Fire, so I had a few (mostly incorrect) assumptions about what the Secret Service does and how they do it.

As it turns out, the Secret Service began as an anti-counterfeiting unit within the Treasury Department.  After Lincoln's assassination fake currency was a big problem, and the Secret Service was charged with rooting out counterfeiters.  It wasn't until much later that the Secret Service was tasked with protecting the President from assassination, and it was even later that the Secret Service was removed from the Treasury Department, freed from weeding out counterfeiters, and folded into the Department of Homeland Security.

And as we all now know, sometime between JFK's assassination and the present day the Secret Service grew less professional, less efficient, and less admired by the general public.  Somewhere along the way the Secret Service became more of an exclusive boy's club, in which agents spend their time off getting drunk and hiring prostitutes in foreign locales.  Many within the Service's ranks have been publicly shamed for such antics, but the organization as a whole has been slow to adapt to changing times.

Not that the Service was always in such desperate need of reform.  No one's blaming them for Kennedy.  It was a long slide downhill, and the worst moments seem to have occurred from the Obama administration onward.

So yeah, all of the above is what I now know about the Secret Service.  I'm no expert, but Zero Fail has taught me a few things I didn't already know.  This said, it's not an especially interesting book, and the insights it offers aren't as wide-ranging as I had hoped for.  Everything before Obama was, for the most part, old news to me, and I often felt like the author should have started the book with that presidency.  Going all the way back to the origins of the Service didn't offer that much more context, and I felt that bringing more recent personalities to the forefront would have made for a more interesting narrative.

And you know what?  The Service's failures during the Trump administration aren't even the most interesting parts of this book.  My mom won't want to hear that of course, and I won't try to convince her one way or the other, but yeah, the juiciest bits happened before Trump was even up for election.

Related Entries:

2022年9月26日 星期一

Some Other Movies From 1940-1949 (2)


For further background on the year in film, please refer to the Some Other Movies From 1940-1949 entry.

The following things happened between 1940 and 1949:
  • Harry S. Truman was sworn in as President of the U.S.
  • Mahatma Gandhi agitated against the British government in India.
  • The Cold War began.
  • World War II ended.
  • U.S. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt died.
  • The Nazis took power in Germany.
All of the movies below can be viewed on YouTube and are linked accordingly.  The ones I liked more are near the top, and the ones I didn't like as much are near the bottom.


1. Nightmare Alley (1947)

I think the original is a lot more to the point that Guillermo del Toro's recent remake.  It draws a clearer line between ego, guilt and addiction.  Star Tyrone Power was an excellent choice for the lead, and the touches del Toro added to the story were, in my opinion, unnecessary.

Fun Fact: This movie had a relatively large budget for the time period, and many of the stars were already established names.  A working carnival was created as part of the production, and actual carnival people were hired to make the setting more authentic.

2. Pinky (1949)

I'd like to say this movie was pushing boundaries, but the sad fact is that in many parts of the world this movie is still pushing boundaries.  Some might say we've come a long way, while others might say we still have a long way to go.

In Pinky Jeanne Crain stars as a racially mixed woman coming to terms with the Southern town where she grew up.  For Crain taking the role was a risky proposition, but under Elia Kazan's direction her character's personal struggle rings true.  Kazan wasn't that happy with Crain's performance, but this movie did very well financially.


There are two great performances at the center of this movie. On the one hand you've got Jennifer Jones, who'd go on to win an Oscar for Best Actress.  On the other hand you've got Vincent Price, who commands every scene he's in.  The Song of Bernadette follows the trials of a young woman who witnesses The Virgin Mary near the town of Lourdes. It's a very Catholic movie, but thought-provoking nonetheless.

Fun Fact: Jennifer Jones' last movie was The Towering Inferno in 1974.


4. Our Town (1940)

Life and death in rural New Hampshire. It was adapted from the play, and composer Aaron Copland wrote the score. I don't know that the theological bits near the end would say as much to modern audiences, but certain characters breaking the fourth wall anticipates more modern approaches to storytelling.

5. The Way Ahead (1944)

David Niven leads a platoon of British infantrymen to battle in North Africa. It gets (if you'll excuse the slight pun) a bit bogged down in the details of their training, but the characters are compelling and the production values were high.

6. Young Widow (1946)

Jane Russell plays a woman mourning her husband near the end of WWII, with Louis Hayward as a serviceman trying to stalk his way into her heart. Given the delayed release of The Outlaw this was Russell's first wide release movie. I can't say that she was a good actress, but Young Widow an interesting look at almost-postwar America.



Detective story in which a mysterious assailant seeks revenge on a wealthy family.  This movie is very short but very well written.

Fun Fact: This movie is part of a series featuring the same detective. There were seven in all, and this was the fifth.


A group of strangers, each accused of murder, face justice on a remote island. It was adapted from an Agatha Christie novel. It's not bad overall, even if the people on the island seem both unnaturally calm and weirdly slow on the uptake in the face of grave danger.

Fun Fact: This is one of five film adaptations of Christie's story.


Eddie Cantor teaches a class of 40 free spirited young ladies. In 2022 about 40% of this movie's plot would be a setup for porn, and about 20% would be grounds for numerous sexual harassment complaints.  Even so I'll be darned if the ending didn't bring a smile to my face.

Fun Fact: Veronica Lake appears briefly in this movie. The following year's I Wanted Wings (below) brought her to the public's attention.


10. I Wanted Wings (1941)

Like The Way Ahead, not just a movie but also a recruitment advertisement for its particular branch of the service.  It was a very popular movie at the time, and also won an Academy Award for special effects, but I never found the characters that engaging. For what it's worth William Holden is in both this and Our Town. It was very early in his career.

11. The Undying Monster (1942)

Horror/murder mystery in which those frequenting an old spooky mansion are attacked by a mysterious assailant. Never mind the Inspector's American accent, and never mind the solution to the mystery.  Contemplating such things will give you a headache.


Carmen Miranda. She's annoying in every scene she's in. I think it's safe to say that her appeal is lost on modern audiences.

I feel like this movie was made more for servicemen stationed overseas. Pretty girls, songs, general zaniness. The best I can say about it is that the redhead is very pretty and the songs are inoffensive.


13. The Iron Curtain (1948)

Soviet spies infiltrate Canada.  This movie was based on a real incident, and great pains were taken to film on location, but it's on the slow side for sure.  In 1948 Russia wasn't quite the bogeyman it is today, but sentiment against that country was certainly growing within the U.S. and Canada.  The Iron Curtain's existence is owed in part to the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Un-American Activities, which accused Hollywood of failing to make any anti-Communist movies.

14. The Jolson Story (1946)

Al Jolson!  Just a Jewish boy who wanted to wear blackface and become a star!  And why blackface, you ask?  Because black people, when they're not missing their mammies and eating watermelons, love to sing and dance!  Yeah, 1946 was a long time ago, and this movie really, really hasn't aged well.  I made it about halfway through and had to give up.

This movie, by the way, was a huge hit, a fact which says a lot about both Jolson's popularity and where race relations were in the late 40s.  This movie also bears some striking similarities to The Jazz Singer, a play which was adapted for film and television several times.  The most recent adaptation, which appeared in 1980 and starred Neil Diamond, thankfully did away with the blackface.

Related Entries:

2022年9月5日 星期一

Some Other Movies From 1940-1949


Top Movies by Year

1949: Jolson Sings Again, 1948: The Red Shoes, 1947: Welcome Stranger, 1946: The Best Years of Our Lives, 1945: The Bells of St. Mary's, 1944: Going My Way, 1943: This is the Army, 1942: Mrs. Miniver, 1941: Sergeant York and 1940: Boom Town.

Hit Songs of the Decade

1949: "All I Want for Christmas is My Two Front Teeth" by Spike Jones, 1948: "Buttons and Bows" by Dinah Shore and Her Happy Boys, 1947: "Near You" by Francis Craig and His Orchestra, 1946: "To Each His Own" by Eddy Howard and His Orchestra, 1945: "Sentimental Journey" by Les Brown and His Orchestra, 1944: "Swinging on a Star" by Bing Crosby, 1943: "Paper Doll" by The Mills Brothers, 1942: "White Christmas" by Bing Crosby, 1941: "Chattanooga Choo Choo" by Glenn Miller and His Orchestra and 1940: "Frenesi" by Artie Shaw and His Orchestra.

Popular Novels of the 40s

How Green Was My Valley by Richard Llewellyn, The Keys of the Kingdom by A.J. Cronin, The Song of Bernadette by Franz Werfel, The Robe by Lloyd C. Douglas, Strange Fruit by Lillian Smith, Forever Amber by Kathleen Winsor, The King's General by Daphne du Maurier, The Miracle of the Bells by Russel Janney, The Big Fisherman by Lloyd C. Douglas and The Egyptian by Mika Waltari.

All of the movies discussed below can be viewed in their entirety on YouTube.  Every title is linked to the full version.

These movies are listed in the order I enjoyed them, with the ones I liked more closer to the top and the ones I liked less closer to the bottom.



Rita Hayworth.  She really was very beautiful.

This was more of a genre picture for Orson Welles, but it's full of interesting touches.  I loved that business with the chess board in the courthouse, and the funhouse in the end.  There's also Hayworth's character, who's twisting and turning at every opportunity.  Welles himself, ridiculous brogue aside, is also an interesting lead, and I liked how his ambivalence plays into both the plot and others' intentions for him.

Fun Fact 1: Welles' cut of the film was very different.  Studio head Harry Cohn objected to Welles' rough cut and ordered both reshoots and a re-editing of the film.  This process took over a year, and resulted in a very different movie.

Harry Cohn, by the way, has been described as "a monster."  You want to talk about #MeToo?  He abused women in the film industry for years with near-impunity.  He was also deeply involved with organized crime.  He was one of the inspirations behind the Jack Woltz character in The Godfather.

Fun Fact 2: Orson Welles' last, unfinished film, The Other Side of the Wind, is available on Netflix.  If you're the kind of person who can sit through F for Fake without falling asleep you might like it.  I'm not, and I didn't.


Jimmy Stewart stars as a reporter trying to prove a convicted murderer's innocence.  The filmmakers made every effort to film this movie on location in Chicago, and the result is a suspenseful movie that feels very authentic.  Director Henry Hathaway was perhaps best known for westerns, but his "semidocumentary" movies are worth a look.

3. Lady on a Train (1945)

The adorable Deanna Durbin witnesses a murder from a train window.  This movie would've only been half as fun if they'd taken it seriously.  Instead a lot of the scenes in this almost-noir are played for laughs, and the result is a movie that's aged like wine.

Fun Fact 1: That really is Durbin's voice in the musical numbers.  She was quite a talented singer.  She retired from Hollywood in 1949, disenchanted with the persona the industry had created for her.

Fun Fact 2: Ralph Bellamy, who appears in this movie as "Jonathan," would later appear in 1983's Trading Places as Randolph Duke.  His career in film lasted 59 years.


4. Under Capricorn (1949)

A young Irishman newly arrived in Australia comes between a wealthy ex-convict and his eccentric wife.  This was Hitchcock's second color film, and both Ingrid Bergman and Joseph Cotten are captivating in the lead roles.  Critics hated it at the time, but appreciation for Under Capricorn has grown considerably since its release.

Fun Fact: The screenplay was written in part by Hume Cronyn.

5. Caught (1949)

Film noir* in which a young woman attempts to leave her abusive husband.  It's a really solid movie all the way through, even if the ending is "upbeat" in the weirdest way possible.  And check out James Mason on this one.  He was young back then.


A British family between world wars.  Written by Noel Coward, This Happy Breed is a very understated movie in which ordinary, working class people live their lives in the shadow of historic events which are at once larger and smaller than themselves.  I loved the father character's dry sense of humor.

Fun Fact: This was director David Lean's second movie.



This movie was remade in 1953 as Vicki, which has also been reviewed here. I think the original works much better in terms of pacing, and Victor Mature is a stronger lead.  Sure, he has an odd way of smiling while talking, but he's much more interesting to watch.

Fun Fact: The scene where the suspected murderer and the murdered woman's sister hide out in the theater is often cited as an example of what "grindhouse theaters" of the time were like.  The movie advertised on the marquee is, by the way, entirely fictional.  There's a 1922 silent film by that name, but the title was re-invented for I Wake Up Screaming.

8. Lucky Jordan (1942)

Alan Ladd stars as a gangster drafted into the U.S. Army.  Weirdly enough, parts of this movie are funnier than Jitterbugs below.  The performances are fairly derivative, and no one plays anything for laughs, but you can tell the scriptwriters had fun with the material.

Fun Fact 1: This was Alan Ladd's first leading role.

Fun Fact 2: Alan Ladd's son, Alan Ladd Jr., was president of 20th Century Fox and founder of The Ladd Company.

9. China (1943)

First Alan Ladd crosses paths with German saboteurs in Lucky Jordan (above), then he fights the Japanese in 1943's China.  It's easy to dismiss this movie as propaganda, and references to "Japs" are less than PC in 2022, but speaking as someone who's lived in Taiwan for 22 years, and who's also studied the history of the Republic of China extensively, I think this movie is a fairly balanced picture of the time period.  Given the time it was made and the subject matter, this film could have been a helluva lot more racist than it is, and in terms of representation the Chinese characters are given a lot of agency.

Fun Fact 1: Alan Ladd's character in this movie was (to some extent) the basis for Indiana Jones.

Unsurprising Fact?: All of the actors playing the Japanese characters were Chinese.  It was, as many have pointed out, an uncomfortable time to be of Japanese ancestry.


10. State Fair (1945)

Jeanne Crain, another beauty.  Her career tapered off in the 50s, but in the 40s her popularity was at its height.

I've stated several times in this blog that I'm "not into musicals," but in the context of the 40s I find them a lot easier to digest.  A lot of other film genres simply didn't exist then, and I can see how light entertainment like State Fair would have been a bigger draw at the box office.  This Rodgers and Hammerstein production is a fun hour and a half, and even if you don't like musicals Jeanne Crain is very easy to look at.


If this movie had been made in the 80s it would have been a slasher film.  As it is several young women are murdered off camera, and the viewer has to guess which of the eccentric people living in the house is the murderer.  It's an indisputably well made movie, but I doubt it would scare anyone now.

12. Gunfighters (1947)

Randolph Scott, who may or may not have been Cary Grant's lover, stars as a gunfighter set on giving up his guns.  I had a difficult time focusing on the plot of this movie, but the stuntmen did an obviously great job.  I should read one of Zane Grey's novels one of these days...


13. Hired Wife (1940)

The head of a cement company marries his secretary for business purposes.  Rosalind Russell is charming as the big boss's secretary, but in my opinion the "secretary in love with her boss" trope plays into a lot of stereotypes.  The movie does upend some of these stereotypes for the sake of laughs, but I still wished that Russell's character respected herself enough to tell her boss to go to hell.  Romance, sexual, harassment or sexual assault?  Some scenes in this movie beg the question.

14. Jitterbugs (1943)

"...another fine mess you've gotten me into!"

Laurel and Hardy help one con man to con another.  I don't think the humor has aged well, but if you're wondering what people found funny in 1943 this will give you a good idea.

Related Entries:


*I use the term "film noir" sparingly.  In many people's hands this term just means "dark, black and white movie that deals with crime."  I've heard the argument that "film noir" is actually an earlier Hollywood attempt to make exploitation/grindhouse pictures that dealt with riskier subject matter.  In many instances, especially as one goes further back in time, it can be hard to separate "film noir" from exploitation.