2022年4月18日 星期一

Some Other Movies From 2022

What you see below is what I've seen in the theater, on Netflix or on Disney+.  I'll be adding to this entry as the year goes on.
 

Excellent
 
1. Father Stu
 
I doubt Mel Gibson cares much what the general public thinks about his past indiscretions.  He probably figures that's between himself and God.  I also doubt Mel Gibson cares much about how thoroughly Catholic this movie is, right down to a Christlike figure appearing in a bar.  Mel Gibson probably figures that's another matter between himself and God, and I can't say he's wrong.

I'm not familiar with director Rosalind Ross, but she did a masterful job directing this movie.  Mark Wahlberg, who's been great in other things, is even greater here, turning in a performance that's not only the best thing he's ever done but maybe also the best thing he ever will do.  The supporting cast, including Mel Gibson, is excellent, and although the story might seem a bit rote it's presented in a very heartfelt manner.

Critics haven't been kind to this one -- some even going so far as to say that Wahlberg was miscast -- but critics are often wrong and scores on various websites can be misleading.

2. Nope

Jordan Peele's first genuinely great movie?  I liked Get Out, but I felt that in Us he kind of outsmarted himself.  Nope, by contrast, is a more straightforward movie that dispenses with racial metaphors.  The revelation toward the end is a haunting spectacle, and the characters are all extremely well written.
 

Weird Enough For Ya?

1. Men

Don't ask me what it's about.  In Men director Alex Garland capitalizes on some of the themes he built up in Ex Machina and Annihilation, with this movie being a step further toward the grotesque.  Viewers might struggle with the slow build up, but stick around for the truly astounding effects sequence near the end.  Whatever that effects sequence means, it's likely to remain with you long after the closing credits.

2. Dual

A terminally ill woman chooses to have herself cloned.  The way in which the actors deliver their lines reminded me of Killing of a Sacred Deer.  It's definitely good, even if a couple of the plot points are very predictable.
 

Overrated?

1. Everything Everywhere All At Once

The little big movie of the year.  People are talking Oscars now, and I'm just not sure what Oscars this movie deserves, if any.

On the one hand this movie resonated with me, in that my Taiwanese-American family bears some similarities to the Chinese-American family portrayed in this movie.  I've seen the relationship between my Taiwanese wife and my half Taiwanese daughters play out in ways similar to Michelle Yeoh's relationship with her daughter, but then again neither my wife nor myself have had to deal with parents as strict, and our marriage was never - as far as I know - an object of disapproval.

On the other hand?  As a huge fan of the science fiction genre, I don't get what all the fuss is about.  Jumping between universes is nothing new, moving forward and backward through decision trees is also nothing new, and the martial arts + virtual/augmented reality approach is as old as The Matrix, if not older.  In conceptual terms nothing in this movie seems like a step beyond what's come before, and I have a great dislike for any science fiction movie in which the plot is resolved through the power of love.  You could argue that this movie parodies such trends in science fiction, but even that angle isn't new.

I liked it, but I have no desire to see it a second time.  Is it the movie of the year?  I really don't think so.

Fun Fact: Does Michelle Yeoh's husband look familiar?  That's Ke Huy Quan, who played both Short Round in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom and Data in The Goonies.

2. Avatar: The Way of Water

I watched a few interviews with director James Cameron before seeing this movie, and I have to say that some of his criticisms of superhero movies seem a bit strange after watching his newest film.  You know what films Avatar: The Way of Water reminded me of most?  Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame.

Hear me out here.  I'm completely aware that Avatar 2 isn't working with a cast of hundreds (or at least dozens) battling for the fate of the universe, but the feeling I got from Avatar 2 and the feeling I got from the last two Avengers movies was almost exactly the same.  They're all really big movies reliant on tons of CGI, and they make a certain emotional sense, but if you think about certain characters' motivations and how these motivations shape their actions through the course of each movie you'll get a headache.

Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed Avatar 2, but a lot of things in this movie just seem to happen without having any reason for happening.  I understand his reasons for doing so in the movie, but does it really make sense for Jake Sully to take his family from their village?  Do his kids' actions, apart from an adolescent sense of alienation, always ring true?  Ultimately a "character driven" movie like this comes down to a series of decisions, and given the information supplied by the script many of these decisions don't make much sense.

That, and after a while I felt like James Cameron was playing us his greatest hits.  You don't have to look too hard to find elements from Aliens, The Abyss and even Titanic in this movie.  The only things this film is missing is cyborgs and time travel, and for all I know those two things are on the way in Avatar 3.


Some Good Ones

1. The Batman

No, I wasn't blown away by it.  I thought it was good, but they could've cut an hour out of it and had a much better movie.  My favorite part was the car chase.  As beautiful as Zoe Kravitz is, my least favorite part was Catwoman.  I never felt like she was integral to the plot, and removing her scenes would have gone a long way to achieving that two hour runtime.

For me the most frustrating part was the ending, which wasn't quite the plot twist it was made out to be.  I feel that those looking for this type of story - a story of revenge taken to its extreme - would be better served by David Fincher's Seven, which is a far better film.

Is The Batman good?  Yes, I would say that it is.  But it's not The Dark Knight, not by a long shot.

2. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness

Critics complaining about the pacing don't know Sam Raimi.  Go back and watch Spider-Man 2 - that's Sam Raimi.  Go back and watch Army of Darkness - that's Sam Raimi too.  He was obviously trying to get the story underway as quickly as possible, so that he could get to what he's good at: weird, haunted-house type stuff employing odd camera angles and unusual sound effects.  This movie is basically Evil Dead writ large, with a possible difference being that Doctor Strange has more agency.

I liked it but I didn't love it.  It never felt slow to me (unlike The Batman), and the plot is fairly cohesive.  Then again, once you throw magic into the mix most plots are going to feel cohesive, given that the audience isn't aware of magical limitations beyond information characters provide.  If I have a complaint it's that Scarlet Witch should have been the center of this movie, not Doctor Strange.  Making her the protagonist would have streamlined the plot quite a bit, and Doctor Strange, in cinematic terms at least, still doesn't have enough of a personality to merit his own movie.  Multiverse of Madness gives him a bit more backstory, but it's still not enough to empathize with.

Some of the visuals in this movie are a wonder to behold.  I highly recommend watching it in a theater, on the biggest screen possible.  The big reveal everyone's been waiting for?  It's actually somewhat forgettable, and those characters aren't onscreen for very long.

Some of the dialogue in this movie is extremely corny but I'll let that pass.  That's Sam Raimi too, and I think that some of this movie's corniness serves to lighten the overall mood.

I could be wrong, but with all the talk of "incursions" in this movie the MCU seems to be moving toward something like Jonathan Hickman's Secret Wars.  Given the Fantastic Four's role in that storyline and the release order this seems likely to me.  I get why people would think Secret Invasion after the appearance of the Skrulls earlier on, but I'm betting on Secret Wars.  Only time will tell if I'm right or wrong in this assumption.

3. The Contractor

Chris Pine and Ben Foster, who also appeared together in Hell or High Water, star as two Army Rangers sent to Germany by a private contractor.  It was a box office bomb and critics weren't fond of it, but beyond the formulaic subject matter there are still some good performances in this movie.

4. X

A group of people find themselves hunted by a killer in the course of shooting an adult film.  I was fully prepared to hate this movie, but despite its heavy reliance on the Texas Chainsaw Massacre franchise it was well done.

Fun Fact 1: This movie was shot entirely in New Zealand.  This isn't the first time New Zealand has stood in for Texas.

Fun Fact 2: There actually is a pornographic film from the 70s titled The Farmer's Daughters.  I saw it not long ago.  The plot of that film has nothing to do with this one.

5. Top Gun: Maverick

Better than the original in my opinion.  Tom Cruise is again called upon to defend America from her enemies abroad, this time leading a group of younger pilots into battle.  Aside from an improbable F-14, the screenplay was tightly written, trading in enough nostalgia to satisfy fans of the original while adding newer elements to keep things interesting.  Tom Cruise, by the way, delivers some great acting in this film.  It's one of the best things he's ever done. 

6. Hustle

Adam Sandler transfers his Uncut Gems credits over to Netflix.  Hustle isn't nearly as good as Uncut Gems, but Sandler makes for a convincing NBA scout and this story hits all the right notes.

7. Thor: Love and Thunder

Forget about any of the comic books, whatever this movie is has nothing to do with what those comic books are.  It's a fun ride for sure, but you'll want to forget about the source material.  In this installment Thor in both male and female incarnations face(s) off against Gorr the God Butcher.  If you walk in expecting an action comedy you won't be disappointed, but if you walk in with a more critical mindset you'll be picking this movie apart in no time.

Korg could have been eliminated from the story altogether, but as we all know it's Taika Waititi's movie, and Korg gives him an excuse to inject more of his sarcastic humor into the script.  Thor: Love and Thunder is Thor: Ragnarok writ even larger, and that fact won't please everyone.

For me the highlight of this movie was Christian Bale.  More scenes of him chopping his way through various pantheons would have made this movie much better.
 
8. The Northman
 
Conan the Barbarian?  The Odyssey?  The Northman invites those kinds of comparisons, but that doesn't mean it's an unoriginal film.  No, director Robert Eggers actually drew on much older material to craft this story of revenge, and the result is a very stylish movie that pulls no punches.  I get why it didn't do that well at the box office though.  It's very dark and not exactly action packed.

9. Day Shift

Jamie Foxx hunts vampires.  It's ridiculous, it doesn't make a lot of sense, but it's also a lot of fun.

10. Werewolf by Night

It's not very long, and it's not especially deep, but this movie scores serious style points.  Anyone else remember those late 70s/early 80s monster-y Marvel Comics?  Werewolf by Night captures that mood exactly.

11. Hellraiser

I'm sure there's a subset of horror fanatics who've enshrined the original, but in almost purely objective terms this movie is the best in the series by far.  The setup makes sense, the characters are believable, and even if it gets a bit derivative toward the end it's never boring.  I've always felt that the Hellraiser movies wasted a great concept, and this film goes some distance to finally getting it right.

12. DC League of Super Pets

It's a funny movie.  Krypto leads a group of newly-empowered pets against a guinea pig bent on world domination.  It hits all the right notes without taking itself too seriously.

13. Black Adam

I don't get why so many people are so down on this movie.  I thought it was really good.  The fight scenes were great, Dwayne Johnson is a convincing Black Adam, and it was fun to finally see Dr. Fate on the big screen.  

Sure, this movie has problems.  Black Adam speaking English like a native after several thousand years' imprisonment was baffling.  The Justice Society has a weird agenda.  The villain at the end is set up about as well as Ares in Wonder Woman.  But overall it's entertaining.  Why all the hate?  If you're avoiding this movie because of sites like CinemaScore and/or Marvel fans with an agenda, you should really give it a chance.

14. Bullet Train

I can't say it's a bad movie, it just made me a bit sleepy.  Brad Pitt stars as a courier trying to get a briefcase off a speeding train, with several lesser known actors as heroes and villains caught up in a gang leader's sinister plans.  Aaron Taylor-Johnson is well used in this movie.

15. Elvis

I can't say it's bad, but is it really about Elvis?  A lot of the music playing in the background isn't his, and what remains is often more of an adaptation of his music than the music itself.  I've never been a fan of director Baz Luhrmann, and this movie hasn't really changed my mind.  Tom Hanks?  Sure, he's great, but I'm still not certain that this is really a movie about Elvis.

For a more down to earth portrait of The King, you might check out 1957's Loving You, which is to some extent based on Elvis's early career.  It's not a great movie, but I think it's a better reflection of Elvis as a person.

Food for Thought: What if they'd made a movie about Little Richard (who appears in this movie) instead?  You think Elvis's life got dark?  You think Elvis's life got weird?  Just check out Little Richard's Wikipedia page.  I can't believe they haven't made a movie about him already.

16. Three Thousand Years of Longing

Tilda Swinton either experiences a psychotic break or frees a genie from a bottle.  Director George Miller shows a great deal of versatility with this movie, and while it's undeniably well done it's a bit too long for its own good.  Back in the 60s they would have inserted an intermission, and that kind of pause would have made this movie better.

17. Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

As I watched this movie I couldn't help but compare it to two other recent films, these being Thor: Love and Thunder and Black Adam.

Why Thor: Love and Thunder?  Because both Thor 4 and Wakanda Forever are very personal statements by their respective directors.  In Thor 4 Taika Waititi showed us that he doesn't care much about comic book canon, character development or coherent storytelling, but that he DOES care a lot about stylistic choices, Guns N' Roses and placing tragic events in a story so that he can make light of them later.  In Wakanda Forever Ryan Coogler shows us the complete opposite: character development and storytelling.  Does this mean that he's disregarded style completely?  By no means.  This movie has its own aesthetic, and this aesthetic never comes at the expense of its characters or the world they inhabit.

Why Black Adam?  Because both Black Adam and Wakanda Forever put superheroes into a third world context, offering us nations and (anti)heroes unwilling to align themselves with the current order of things.  Black Adam happily destabilizes the larger powers he comes into contact with, while the characters in Wakanda Forever walk a much finer line between asserting dominance and pretending submission.

Black Adam was the stompy superhero movie I was waiting for, but I liked Wakanda Forever too.  Hats off to what this movie did with Namor, "Atlantis" and Namor's origin story.  Not only did the script succeed in differentiating Namor from Aquaman, but Namor's origin also ties nicely into the larger narrative.  No, Namor was never Mayan in the comics (NOT canon!), but I think the change was necessary given the story they were trying to tell.


Not As Bad As I Was Led To Believe

1. Morbius

Jared Leto stars as the living vampire.  Is this the worst movie ever made?  Far from it.  Is it the worst superhero movie ever made?  No, not even close.  It's a 90s-style superhero film along the lines of Venom 2: Let There Be Carnage.  The actions taken by the two detectives don't bear thinking about, but overall it's harmless fun and the fight at the end is cool enough.

I can only hope that Michael Keaton doesn't visit casinos.  Between Sony's Whatever-It-Is Cinematic Universe and The Flash his future in superhero movies isn't exactly bright.  I'm sure he'll be fine, but I'm not expecting to see either the Vulture or his version of Batman in too many future films.
 

Uh... What?

1. Dirty Little Secret

It's a Lifetime movie, I'm a high school student with dreams of attending the "Fashion Institute of Technology," and... my mom's a hoarder!  Standard Lifetime fare, right?  The difference being the ending, which is so dark and depressing it's almost worth sitting through the rest of the movie for.  I really don't know what happened there, maybe they ran out of money and/or stopped caring, but whatever happened it's certainly the most nihilistic Lifetime movie ever.


Some Bad Ones

1. Uncharted

Half as plausible as both F9 and Spider-Man: No Way Home, while at the same time only half as interesting as either of those movies.  Tom Holland spends a great deal of time hopping around, trying to remind us that he's not Spider-Man, and Mark Wahlberg is always one step behind him.  In F9 you can pretend they're Hot Wheels, and in Spider-Man you can remind yourself that they're superheroes, but in this movie the historical inaccuracies pile up to the point where it takes you right out of the movie.  It's not Indiana Jones, it's not National Treasure, and it's not even Tomb Raider.  It kind of just is, and its being there isn't enough to make it worth watching.

Fun Fact 1: This was originally going to be a very, very different kind of movie.  Mark Wahlberg was attached early on, but he was going to star in a film directed by David O. Russell, who'd recently directed Wahlberg in The Fighter.  There were also plans to have Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci appear alongside Wahlberg, but David O. Russell and Robert De Niro went on to do Silver Linings Playbook instead.

Fun Fact 2: This movie is banned in both the Philippines and Vietnam.  Both countries objected to the inclusion of the nine-dash line in a map of the region.  This nine-dash line supports China's claim to territories that both the Philippines and Vietnam claim sovereignty over.

2. Scream

Yawn.  I liked the opening, but after that I had trouble paying attention.  Sure, it's more meta for your money, but the characters are really bad at defending themselves and no one ever thinks to call the police.  Or what about, you know, just leaving town?  Isn't it really that town that always kills them?  I know people are clamoring for a sequel, but I'm officially done with this franchise.  Back in the day it was fun to guess who the killer(s) might be.  Now it's not.

Fun Fact 1: Jenna Ortega, who plays Tara Carpenter, is also in X above.

Fun Fact 2: Jack Quaid isn't the only son of famous parents in the cast.  Mason Gooding is Cuba Gooding Jr.'s son.

3. Jurassic World Dominion

Like Scream another "legacy sequel."  In this one people continue to run from dinosaurs.  If they are virtuous they eventually run to safety, or at least to a continued niche in an uncertain ecosystem.  If they are greedy or vicious they are chomped by said dinosaurs, and denied repeat appearances in inevitable sequels.

4. Spiderhead

A scientist tests out his emotion-inducing compounds on a group of convicts.  I thought Miles Teller was excellent in this movie, but Chris Hemsworth was miscast.
 
5. Followers
 
British.  Found footage.  Social media influencers.  Ghosts.  If you're 14 you'll be all over this one, if you're older and you've seen a few horror movies you won't.

6. Prey

The Predator vs. Native Americans!  Sounds interesting, but the Native Americans seemed implausibly modern to me, while the Predator seemed strangely forbearing.  I was fully invested in this movie for about twenty minutes and then completely lost interest.

7. Blonde

I'm not trying to score points here, and I'm not trying to be politically correct, I just really, really didn't like this movie.  Why is it necessary to oversexualize someone who was already oversexualized during their lifetime?  I won't argue that there aren't some amazing shots in this film, but I don't feel that it's really about Marilyn Monroe.  What's next, a movie about Jayne Mansfield featuring double anal penetration?  If I want to watch porn I'll just go watch porn.  I have no desire to watch a mean-spirited drama hiding behind a famous name.

Director Andrew Dominik seems to have adopted a scorched earth policy with regard to the press tour.  In a way I get his frustration, but I also think a lot of the criticism is justified.  They could have easily NOT made this movie about Marilyn Monroe.  They could have used a stand-in.  The resulting film would have been much better received.

8. Halloween Kills

"Suicide or cherry blossoms," huh?

The thing that really kills this movie, if you'll excuse the slight pun, is Laurie Strode's voiceovers.  That, and a badly written script.  I've never been a fan of the franchise, but this movie makes the ones that came before it look relatively polished.  The actor who plays Michael Myer's protege is good, but he's drowning in a sea of bad dialog and nonsensical plot points.

9. Samaritan

Sylvester Stallone stars as a retired boxer - sorry, as a retired superhero - who strikes up a friendship with a young boy.  The second half of this movie has some cringy moments but it's obviously for kids.  As with Morbius above it seems more like something we would have seen in the 90s.

10. Where the Crawdads Sing

I finished the novel right before watching the movie.  The novel is WAY better.  The movie fails spectacularly to capture Kya's sense of loneliness and alienation, and it is this sense of otherness that drives the plot of the book.  Without that sense of otherness we're left with a tired romantic triangle overshadowing an inexplicable court case, and neither the romantic triangle nor the court case make any kind of impression on the viewer.


Gloriously Terrible

1. Moonfall

I f*&king loved it from start to finish.  This is indeed Roland Emmerich's masterpiece, a bizarre, disorienting concatenation of scientific concepts, bad acting, laughable dialog and special effects that detract rather than add to the story.  Sign me up for the sequel - I'll be there the first day.

Related Entries:

2022年4月6日 星期三

"A Brief History of Seven Killings" by Marlon James (2014)


"I couldn't help it, I'm already looking for boys and especially girls from my high school, who found the true light of Rasta, but are really here just to give their uptown parents grief.  There's just so much sex you can have with a man who doesn't use deodorant or a woman who doesn't shave her armpits or legs.  Maybe to be a real Rasta you have to be into man musk and woman fish.  A lot of women but they are all moving.  It takes me a while to see that they are all getting something to give to the men, food, a stool, water, matches for their weed, more food, juice from big Igloos.  Livication and liberation my ass.  If I wanted to live in a Victorian novel I at least want men who know how to get a decent haircut."

Marlon James is a Jamaican writer living in Minnesota.  He's written several novels and teaches at Macalester College in St. Paul.  A Brief History of Seven Killings seems to be the most recognized of his books, and it earned him a Man Booker Prize a year after its publication.

The first half of this book centers around a plot to kill Bob Marley (referred to as "The Singer") on the eve of his peace concert in Jamaica.  As any Wikipedia search will tell you, this plot ultimately fails, and Marley lives on to see the 80s, during which time he dies of cancer.  From the failed murder plot the author moves on to New York in the 80s and 90s, detailing the doings of several Jamaican gangsters, drug smugglers and exiles in the city that never sleeps.

I want to say that this book didn't deserve the Man Booker Prize, but that's not the case.  I've read other Man Booker Prize winners, and compared to those other, inferior books A Brief History of Seven Killings isn't bad.  I can't say that it's consistently entertaining, but there are certain parts of it that I genuinely enjoyed.

This said, I had four big problems with this book.  They were:

1. It was really too long.  The author could have told the same story in far fewer pages.

2. Some of the characters near the beginning are too similar.  It's hard to tell them apart, and giving some of them their own chapters was just confusing.

3. This book doesn't always feel like a cohesive whole.  The chapters focusing on female characters were excellent - in particular the story of a Jamaican woman trying to marry her way out of Jamaica - but these chapters often feel like short stories stitched together between the doings of gangsters, rather than parts of a seamless narrative in which every chapter is necessary.

4. The dialogue doesn't always ring true.  Take the Tristan character, for example.  Would a tough guy like that really rattle on in a conversation?  Would he talk and talk, describing his thought processes and various exploits, without a pause?  I can't imagine someone that hardcore talking that much, regardless of who was present.

As for the power struggle between the various gangs (posses) and the CIA, I enjoyed it, even if it seemed a little too much like something James Ellroy would have written.  Josey Wales, one of the main characters, and Weeper, one of his lieutenants, were interesting personalities, but they were spread too thinly over a lengthy book, and the way they jump into and out of the story is perplexing.  I'm not saying that because the author is gay that he can't write convincing gangsters, but I did often feel that he was closer to his female characters, and that they were more fully realized versions of living, breathing people.

The ending of this book is solid however.  It just takes a while to get there.  I'm guessing that the author wrote better books after this one, and it's just that these books haven't gotten as much attention.  I probably won't seek out other books by Marlon James, but if I stumble across one I might give it a shot.

Related Entries:

2022年4月5日 星期二

Some Other Movies From 1970


The Top Movies of 1970

Popular movies released in 1970 include Love Story, Airport, M*A*S*H, Patton, Woodstock, Little Big Man, Tora! Tora! Tora!, Ryan's Daughter, Catch-22, The Owl and the Pussycat, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, Scrooge, Downhill Racer, Tell Them Willie Boy is Here, Diary of a Mad Housewife, Women in Love, Kes, and They Shoot Horses Don't They?.


Popular Albums of 1970

Popular albums of the year include Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon and Garfunkel, Abbey Road - the Beatles, Led Zeppelin II - Led Zeppelin, Deja Vu - Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young, McCartney - Paul McCartney, Let It Be - the Beatles, The Woodstock Soundtrack, Blood, Sweat and Tears 3 - Blood, Sweat and Tears, Cosmo's Factory - Creedence Clearwater Revival, Abraxas - Santana, Led Zeppelin III - Led Zeppelin and Sunflower - The Beach Boys.


1970 Books Later Adapted Into Movies

Love Story by Erich Segal, The French Lieutenant's Woman by John Fowles, The Fantastic Mr. Fox by Roald Dahl and Play it as it Lays by Joan Didion.


Major Sporting Events of 1970

The Kansas City Chiefs won the Super Bowl, legendary football coach Vince Lombardi died, the Baltimore Orioles won the World Series, the Boston Bruins won the Stanley Cup, Mark Spitz broke his own world record in swimming and Eddy Merckx continued to dominate the world of cycling.


Comic Books in 1970

Charlton Comics published its last comic book, the first San Diego Comic-Con was organized and Jack Kirby penciled his last issue of Fantastic Four.


Excellent

1. Five Easy Pieces

Jack Nicholson stars as an angry young man attempting to escape the life laid out for him.  It was nominated for four Academy Awards and won none of them.  It is however regarded as one of the first films in the "New Hollywood" movement.

Neither Nicholson nor his costar Karen Black were new to acting at the time.  Nicholson had been in movies since 1958 and Black had been in movies since 1960.  You could say that Black's career peaked with 1975's Nashville, while most of Nicholson's best work was still ahead of him.

2. The Ballad of Cable Hogue

Jason Robards finds an oasis in the Wild West, and Stella Stevens is a woman bent on a better life.  Sam Peckinpah directed this one, and it might just be the best thing he ever did.

Fun Fact: Stella Stevens is the mother of Andrew Stevens, whom she give birth to when she was 16.  Andrew Stevens played Kirk Douglas's son in The Fury.

3. Little Big Man

It's tempting to reassess Dancing With Wolves in the presence of this movie, but there are many stories of white men integrating into Native American tribes, some from the time period and some written later on.  Needless to say Dustin Hoffman is excellent in this movie, and Little Big Man has aged like wine.  The director, Arthur Penn, also helmed Bonnie and Clyde three years before.


Excellent but Depressing

1. Clickety Clack (a.k.a. Dodesukaden)

Life at the bottom of postwar Japanese society.  Director Akira Kurosawa paints a vivid portrait of a world where small acts of forgiveness mean everything, and where people struggle to make amends for past mistakes.  This was Kurosawa's first film shot in color, and the cast consists of relative unknowns.


Casts a Shadow

1. The Dunwich Horror

I have the feeling this movie was a huge influence on Sam Raimi.  He would have been 11 years old when it hit theaters, and there are many, many parallels between this movie and Evil Dead.

In terms of atmosphere this movie is an admirable success.  I just wish the two leads (Dean Stockwell and Sandra Dee) were better actors.  If they'd had the budget for someone REALLY good, say Oliver Reed, this movie would have been so much better.  I haven't read the Lovecraft story in decades, but I think the film does a good job or channeling Lovecraft's sense of existential threat.

Fun Fact: Talia Shire (billed here as Talia Coppola) is in this movie briefly.  This was her second movie.


Some Good Ones

1. Patton

Can't beat that opening monologue.  The word "iconic" is a bit overused now, but that opening monologue is one of the most iconic moments in the history of film.  I used to work with a guy who could recite the entire thing from memory.  We'd be standing in a UPS sorting hub, and when the mood struck him he'd rattle off that speech, sounding a lot like George C. Scott as he did so.

I feel like this movie has two stars.  One of them is George C. Scott, who in Patton won the role of a lifetime, and alongside him there's Francis Ford Coppola's script, which does an excellent job of shrinking a global conflict down to very human dimensions.

For fans of Coppola's The Godfather trilogy there's also an Italian connection in this movie, in that Patton's drive through Sicily introduces the island which Michael Corleone would escape to after killing the cop and the rival mob boss in The Godfather.  Sicily was where the Corleones originated, and Coppola would also revisit the area in The Godfather Part II and III.  The parts of Patton set in Sicily were actually shot in Spain, while those parts of The Godfather trilogy were actually shot in Sicily, but the connection is there regardless.

Patton won seven Academy Awards, including one for Best Actor, which George C. Scott declined.  I'm not including it in the "Excellent" category because it really is a bit slow at times.  I love the picture it paints of Patton and his time period, but I think some of the battle scenes - wonderfully staged as they are - could have been cut from the movie.

Fun Fact: There's a made-for-TV sequel to this, also starring George C. Scott, by the name of The Last Days of Patton.

2. A Swedish Love Story

I can't say it's bad, but it's not exactly riveting.  Oh, and Swedish kids smoke (smoked?) A LOT.  In A Swedish Love Story a young girl and a young boy fall in love while trying to cope with various family issues.  It's not exactly fast-paced, but if you're in a more reflective mood you might like it.

Fun Fact: Actor Bjorn Andreson, who has a minor role in this movie, also played the object of the protagonist's desire in Death in Venice the following year.  More recently he had a bit part in Midsommar.

3. Zabriskie Point

A young man takes up arms for the Revolution, finds love in the desert, and ultimately seeks his own destruction.  It's very much in line with the Easy Rider school of filmmaking, but I'm not altogether sure what director Michelangelo Antonioni was trying to say with this movie.  It was a financial disappointment for the studio, and is now better remembered for its soundtrack, which leans heavily on Pink Floyd.

Fun Fact: That jail scene in the beginning?  Harrison Ford is in there somewhere.

4. Bed and Board (a.k.a. Domicile Conjugal)

Francois Truffaut directed this story of marital ups and downs.  In some ways it reminded me of Bergman's Scenes From a Marriage, though it's certainly a lot less depressing.

Fun Fact: Hiroko Matsumoto, who plays a supporting role in Bed and Board, is considered the first Japanese supermodel.  She died under mysterious circumstances in 2003.  Despite a celebrated modeling career, Bed and Board is the only movie she ever appeared in.

5. The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes

Sherlock Holmes is....?  No, not really, and instead of pursuing that more interesting idea this movie takes a detour into a derivative detective story full of oh-so-convenient clues.  The Bible open to the story of Jonah and the whale?  The birds placed inside the coffin?  Scaling down Holmes' analytical prowess is one thing, but this movie makes the solution to the case seem almost accidental.

6. Santa Claus is Coming to Town

Rankin/Bass joint exploring Santa's origins.  Did you enjoy the Will Ferrell movie Elf?  If so, you'll probably enjoy this one, too.

7. Woodstock: The Director's Cut

3 Days of Peace & Music, man.  Many refer to Woodstock as the defining moment of the late 1960s, but it casts a shadow over the early 70s as well.  And where did all those self-described "freaks" wind up in the early 70s?  Some of them wound up in Vietnam, others overdosed, others started communes, and still others went on to live relatively normal lives, untouched by the world-shattering events they sought to influence.  

In my opinion the director's cut of Woodstock is far better than the theatrical version, in that it offers a larger perspective on the concert and what it meant to people at the time.

Fun Fact: Martin Scorsese was one of the editors on this movie.

Take a Breath, and Then, for a Harsh Jolt of Reality: Watch the Netflix documentaries Woodstock 99: Peace, Love and Rage or Trainwreck: Woodstock 99.  I've seen the second of these documentaries, and yeah, I doubt that being at Woodstock 99 is something many parents are going to brag to their children about.


Some Bad Ones

1. Cromwell

Relentlessly melodramatic, while at the same time consistently uninteresting.  There's NO WAY that conversation between Cromwell and the English king ever happened.  If he'd said those things he would have been dead soon after.  For what it's worth Richard Harris stars as Cromwell, with Alec Guinness as the king.

2. Start the Revolution Without Me

Gene Wilder and Donald Sutherland star as two pairs of identical twins separated at birth on the eve of the French Revolution.  Wilder is very much in his element, but Sutherland was miscast and most of the humor (if you can call it that) hasn't aged well.

3. The Vampire Lovers (a.k.a. The Kiss of the Vampire)

An incredibly slow witted couple encounter vampires during their honeymoon.  For me the most maddening part of this movie was the doctor, or professor, or whatever he is.  Why couldn't he just warn them away from the beginning?  Why was he so obscure about what was going on?  This is a Hammer film, and also features Ingrid Pitt from Countess Dracula, but in 1970 they had yet to ramp up the sex and the result is a talky, uneventful movie that promises little and offers even less.


Well, Woodstock is Over, On to the Boobies I Guess...

1. Beyond the Valley of the Dolls

Auteur director par excellance Russ Meyer flawlessly executes this tale of an all-girl rock group seeking fame in Los Angeles.  And who wrote the script?  Could it be noted film critic Roger Ebert?  Why, yes it could be!

The "hip" dialogue in this movie is hilarious.  That, and everyone in this thinly veiled morality tale is ridiculously easy to look at.  If I had to pick one to fall in love with, I'd choose the drummer in Kelly's band.  She's adorable.

Fun Fact: Pam Grier is in this for a second.

Personal Reflection: I knew a woman like the "porn actress" in this film, and yeah, after a while you'd rather just do it in a bed.


Grainy, Grainy Porn

1. Mona the Virgin Nymph

Let's see if I can remember the plot:
  • Mona and her husband-to-be are on a picnic.  They start fooling around, but Mona refuses to go all the way before they're married.
  • Mona goes home to meet her mother, who goes on to explain that Mona's vow to remain chaste until her wedding day has something to do with Mona's father, who died three years ago.
  • Mona blows some guy in an alley.  She then asks for his phone number, stating that she only wants to meet at a later date so that she can blow him again.
  • Mona meets another woman in the same alley.  They have a lesbian encounter at an undisclosed location.
  • Mona goes back home and talks to her mother.  Mona, frustrated with her husband-to-be working overtime for the third day in a row, decides to go see a movie.
  • Mona's mother starts reading a racy novel after Mona leaves, and begins masturbating in the living room.
  • Mona's boyfriend arrives at Mona's house, looking for his fiancé.  He runs into Mona's mother instead, who insists that they fuck.
  • Mona blows another guy at the movie theater.  Her boyfriend later shows up and catches her in the act.
  • Mona's fiancé ties her up in a bedroom, and uses her address book to call the guy Mona blew in the alley, the woman she had a lesbian encounter with, and the other guy she blew in the movie theater.
  • An orgy ensues.  The camera then pans across the length of Mona's mother's dildo.  On the other end of this dildo are written the words "The End."
Mona the Virgin Nymph is a harmless trifle of a movie, much like other pornographic films from the early 70s.  It's not worth seeking out on its own merits, but if you're bored some of the dialogue will bring a smile to your face.  Is it sexy?  No, but it'll remind you that the early 70s were a more innocent time, when people in porn didn't go from "Hello" to double anal penetration  in 60 seconds or less.

Fun Fact 1: This movie had a theatrical release.  Plot elements from this movie were later borrowed for Deep Throat.

Fun Fact 2: This movie cost about $7,000 to make and went on to earn $2 million.


WTF in Cinematic Terms

1. Twinky (a.k.a. Lola or London Affair)

Charles Bronson stars as a 38 year old man WHO MARRIES A 16 YEAR OLD GIRL.  And it's played like a romantic comedy.  I "kid" you not.  In 1970 someone was cool with this.  Charles Bronson, 16-year old girl... yep.

Oh, and I almost forgot.  This movie was directed by Richard Donner.  Yes, that Richard Donner.  Superman.  The Goonies.  That Richard Donner.

I'm only thankful that actress Susan George was 19 at the time of filming.  Not 16, mind you, 19 years old.  She sure did look 16 though.

Related Entries:

2022年3月21日 星期一

Some Other Movies From 1971 (2)


For further background on the year in film, please refer to the Some Other Movies From 1971 entry.

The following things happened in 1971:
  • The world population experienced its highest increase (in terms of percentage of previous population) in history.
  • All in the Family aired for the first time on TV.
  • The Aswan High Dam opened in Egypt.
  • Charles Manson and 3 members of his "family" were found guilty of the Tate-LaBianca murders.
  • The Nasdaq Composite stock market index debuted in the U.S.
  • The Weather Underground claimed responsibility for the bombing of the United States Capitol.
  • East Pakistan (now known as Bangladesh), Qatar, Oman and Bahrain declared independence.
  • The My Lai Massacre took place in Vietnam.
  • The first Starbucks opened in Seattle, Washington.
  • Jim Morrison died.
  • Gloria Steinem addressed the women of America.
  • President Nixon ended the Bretton Woods system, which fixed the value of the dollar to a certain amount of gold.
  • A riot occurred at Attica Prison in New York.
  • Greenpeace was founded in Canada.
  • The first microprocessor was released by Intel.
  • The Khmer Rouge began their assault on Cambodian government positions.
Linked entries can be viewed in their entirety on YouTube.


Excellent

1. Wake in Fright

A schoolteacher on his way to Sydney is detained in the Outback.  Wake in Fright is definitely not a film for animal lovers, but keep in mind that the scenes involving animal deaths were filmed separate from the movie itself, and involved local hunters.  The director, Ted Kotcheff, would go on to do First Blood and Weekend at Bernie's in the 80s.

2. Two-Lane Blacktop

The Fast and the Furious: 1971 Edition.  James Taylor (yes, that James Taylor!) and Dennis Wilson (of the Beach Boys!) star as two guys driving across American in a souped up car.  And weirdly enough, the car racing that happens in-between conversations is beside the point.  It's a movie that feels like it could have happened yesterday, and moreover a movie full of unorthodox choices.

Fun Fact: The director, Monte Hellman, was second unit director on the original Robocop.

3. Death in Venice

A very lonely, very closeted man journeys to Venice and falls in love.  This Italian adaptation of Thomas Mann's novella manages to communicate all the melancholy and mortal terror present in the original story, while at the same time lavishly recreating the time period.  The star, Dirk Bogarde, threw himself into the role.

4. Vanishing Point

A man in a white Challenger, armed with an envelope full of uppers, is on his way to San Francisco.  It's a masterpiece of minimalistic storytelling, perhaps even more so than the above-mentioned Two-Lane Blacktop.  These two movies would make a great double feature.

Fun Fact 1: The director wanted Gene Hackman for the lead role, but the studio insisted on relative unknown Barry Newman.

Fun Fact 2: The stunt coordinator also put together the car chase in The French Connection.

Fun Fact 3: Cleavon Little would go on to play a DJ a second time in 1978's far inferior FM.  Three years after Vanishing Point he'd star in Blazing Saddles.

5. Harold and Maude

Long before Wes Anderson there was Hal Ashby, that oft-forgotten of 70s auteur directors.  In Harold and Maude a morbid young man and a much older woman fall in love.  It's a movie in which people react in a manner opposite to what's expected, and the ending will stay with you for a long time.


Haunting

1. Johnny Got His Gun

NOW THAT THE WAR IS THROUGH WITH ME

I'M WAKING UP I CANNOT SEE

THAT THERE'S NOT MUCH LEFT OF ME

NOTHING IS REAL BUT PAIN NOW

Man, I've been wanting to see this movie since 1988.  In the late 80s I couldn't find a copy, life happened, and I thought about watching it off and on ever since.  I'm happy to say that now I've finally seen it, and that in many ways this movie surpassed my expectations.  Not only is this story of a maimed and mutilated war casualty more gruesome than the Metallica song it inspired, but it's also an exceptionally well put together film seething with anti-war sentiment.  I'm only sorry it took me so long to finally make this movie's acquaintance.

Fun Fact 1: Dalton Trumbo wrote and directed this in collaboration with Luis Bunuel.  It was based on Trumbo's novel of the same name.

Fun Fact 2: Metallica owns the rights to this film.  They purchased these rights so that they could keep the video of One in rotation.

Fun Fact 3: This was Timothy Bottoms' first movie.  He'd star in The Last Picture Show the same year, and two years after that he'd star in The Paper Chase.

Fun Fact 4: "The Swede" having a conversation with Jesus is actor David Soul, who'd go on to star in the TV show Starsky and Hutch.

2. The Devils

The second I saw director Ken Russell's name I expected quite a ride.  I'm happy to say I wasn't disappointed.

The Devils is around two hours of religious and sexual hysteria.  And Oliver Reed doesn't just star in this movie, he commands it.  Is his Catholic priest a moral or immoral man?  An enlightened or ignorant one?  I suppose that depends entirely on whether you're viewing his actions through the morality of the past or the present, or his sentiments through the popular opinion of his time or ours.  Whichever way you cut it, this is a movie full of brilliant sets, even better acting, and an ending that comes down like a hammer.  Like Johnny Got His Gun it's not a happy film, but it's still very much worth seeing.

Fun Fact 1: This movie was partly adapted from a book by Aldous Huxley.

Fun Fact 2: This movie was rated X and banned in several countries upon its release.

Fun Fact 3: There's a documentary on the making of this movie.  It's often referred to as "one of the most controversial films ever made."


Some Good Ones

1. Red Sun

I'd seen it before, but it was good to see it again.

Charles Bronson stars as a morally ambiguous bank robber, with the great Toshiro Mifune as a samurai on his way to Washington D.C. to deliver a sword.  It's a very concise Western, the characters are well drawn and the plot is the direct product of personal conflicts laid out within the script.

Fun Fact 1: This movie wasn't just a hit in Japan because of Toshiro Mifune.  Charles Bronson was also well known in Japan by that time.  He'd appeared in The Magnificent Seven not long before, which was based on The Seven Samurai, starring Toshiro Mifune.

Fun Fact 2: Ursula Andress, arguably the first Bond girl, is in this film, but that's not the only 007 connection.  The director, Terence Young, also helmed Dr. No, From Russia with Love and Thunderball.

2. Get Carter

Michael Caine puts it on a slow boil as a London gangster looking to avenge his brother's death.  Caine was in his share of bad 70s films, but this isn't one of them.  If the name sounds familiar, it's because there was a 2000 remake with Sylvester Stallone in the lead.

Fun Fact 1: The director, Mike Hodges, would go on to helm Flash Gordon in 1980.

Fun Fact 2: The 1972 blaxploitation film Hit Man, which starred Bernie Casey, was based on the same novel.

3. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory

I know this movie has its champions but I found it a little boring.  It takes FOREVER for the kids to get to the chocolate factory, and by the time they do Willy Wonka interrupts what might have been fun little scenes with a lot of talking.  I'd take Tim Burton's remake any day of the week.  

By no means is the original bad, but I think Burton's Wonka-by-way-of-Bowie worked a lot better.

4. Daughters of Darkness

A stylish exercise in erotic horror, even though the deaths that occur in the course of the film are very improbable.  The director, Harry Kumel, didn't do many films, but some of what he did sounds interesting.

5. Shaft

A Harlem crime boss hires hard boiled detective John Shaft to find his kidnapped daughter.  Shaft is, like Super Fly and Foxy Brown, one of the pillars of the blaxploitation genre, and certainly its most popular film.  It's far from flawless, but it's definitely entertaining and it's aged very well.


Good?  Bad?  Not Sure...

1. Duck, You Sucker! (a.k.a. A Fistful of Dynamite or Once Upon a Time... the Revolution)

Rod Steiger and James Coburn enter the sweaty, dusty world of Sergio Leone.  You can tell the director was swinging for the cheap seats here, perhaps even attempting the Western to end all Westerns, but the results are decidedly mixed.  On the one hand this movie features excellent performances by the two leads, on the other it goes on way too long.  Ending it just after the massacre in the cave would have resulted in a movie that made a more lasting impression.  As it is there's a whole other part after the massacre, which to me felt like little more than the scriptwriter checking off all the remaining boxes.  Traitor?  Dead.  President?  Dead.  Evil general?  Dead.  And I'm not even spoiling the plot by listing those deaths.  After a certain point those deaths are a foregone conclusion.

Certain shots in this film are a wonder to behold.  Unfortunately many of these shots look more like Spain, where this movie was shot, than like Mexico, where the story's supposed to be set.


Some Bad Ones

1. The Organization

A detective (Sidney Poitier) finds himself caught between an idealistic group of young people and a less idealistic group of drug smugglers.  This movie isn't terrible; it's just too convoluted for its own good.  The ending is also rather unsatisfying.

Fun Fact: Raul Julia is in this.  The Organization was his third movie.


The late 60s called and they want their movie back.

I was missing the humor in this film.  The plot has something to do with a particularly difficult secondary school class going on an outdoor excursion.  It was hugely popular in Britain at the time, being a spinoff of a popular TV show. 


So Bad It's Good

1. The Big Boss (a.k.a. Fists of Fury)

You're in Thailand, you've got Bruce Lee on tap, a few pretty girls and around 100 Hong Kong dollars.  Make a movie!  Go!

How's the whole "drug smuggling via blocks of ice" scheme supposed to work, anyway?  Wouldn't it be a lot of trouble to freeze the drugs inside the ice?  Especially in Southeast Asia?  And wouldn't the drugs be easily visible inside the ice?  And it's not like drugs were that hard to transport through Thailand back then.  Why not just pay the cops to look the other way?

Fun Fact 1: Don't get confused.  The U.S. title of this film was FISTS of Fury, not to be confused with the 1972 sequel FIST of Fury.  This movie was Lee's first as leading man.

Fun Fact 2: A lot of the prostitutes in the brothel scene were actual prostitutes.  They filmed some of those scenes in a nearby brothel.

2. Bedknobs and Broomsticks

Had I the wherewithal, I'd compose a black metal album based on this movie.  The last song would be called "Witch in the Sky," and it would be HEAVY AS FUCK.

I got myself pretty drunk while watching this Disney "classic."  Angela "Murder, She Wrote" Lansbury stars as an apprentice witch, with a trio of Disney-mandated British street urchins under her wing.  It's Mary Poppins, in other words, but not nearly as good.

The plot is also pretty random.  Lansbury needs the words to a spell, and the words to the spell are in a book, or they might be on an island ruled by animals, or they might be in another book entirely.  However we get there stuff ends up getting animated by sinister powers ("Asteroth" I think not, "Azathoth" it be...) and then the animated (as in the Latin animus) stuff kicks a bunch of Nazis the fuck off British soul.  Rule Brittania, says I.  

Or something.  I'm not sure.  Again, I was drunk.

Fun Fact 1: Angela Lansbury is STILL ALIVE.  Really.  At the time of writing she's 97 years old.

Fun Fact 2: This movie was shot using yellowscreen, not bluescreen.  The yellowscreen process, also known as the sodium vapor process, involves the use of sodium vapor lights against a white background.  The sodium vapor lights narrow the color spectrum to the point where the special effects can be added to the live action shots.

Related Entries:

2022年3月14日 星期一

"IBM and the Holocaust" by Edwin Black (2001)


First of all, thanks to William D. Finn, of 939 Homer Street, (#3003) in Vancouver, British Columbia.  I don't know how his book found its way to Taiwan, but I thank him just the same.  Feel free to write him a letter if you ever read IBM and the Holocaust.

But I digress.  Yet again.  Here's a quote:

"Interior Ministry officials reviewed one fanciful proposal for a twenty-five-floor circular tower of data to centralize all personal information.  The proposal was rejected because it would take years to build and stock.  But the futuristic concept opened the eyes of Reich planners.  Each of the twenty five floors in the imagined tower would be composed of 12 circular rooms representing one birth year.  Every circular room would contain 31 cabinets, one for each day of the month.  Each cabinet in turn would contain 7,000 names.  Registrations and updates would feed in from census bureaus.  All 60 million Germans would then be organized and cross-indexed in a single location regardless of changes in residence.  Data could be removed by some 1,500 couriers running from room to room like so many magnetic impulses fetching files."

Edwin Black is an investigative journalist and author of several books.  He's the child of Polish Holocaust survivors, and has written often on Nazism, anti-Semitism and human rights.

IBM and the Holocaust is a very detailed, very carefully argued book, and I'll do my best to synopsize its contents.  In the late 1800s an American invented a new form of punch card technology which improved the quality and speed with which the U.S. Census was produced.  The centerpiece of this technology was the Hollerith machine, named after its inventor, Herman Hollerith.

By various twists and turns a business predicated upon this punch card technology became International Business Machines, or IBM, which under new leadership sought to expand outward into international markets.  By that time the company was under the direction of Thomas J. Watson, a cutthroat individual who transformed the company into both an industrial powerhouse and a cult of personality centered around himself.

Somewhere in the middle of all that World War I happened, and IBM, casting a hopeful eye toward postwar Germany, expanded into that country without considering the cost of doing business with the German government.  As part of this process IBM came to set up a subsidiary in Germany by the name of Dehomag, which was completely subservient to IBM's main office in New York.

Hitler happened, and what was his stated goal from the outset?  The extermination of the Jews of course.  And what was the first step in achieving that goal?  Compiling a census, a task with which IBM Germany (i.e. Dehomag) was intimately familiar.

This compiling of a German census involved a lot of collaboration with IBM executives, and as the book makes clear the IBM New York office was kept informed every step of the way.  IBM was there when the Nazis were searching for better ways to profile "social undesirables," and IBM was there when the Nazis were looking for better ways to catalogue people, places and modes of transportation.

And what was the result of all this cataloguing and census-taking?  The Holocaust.  Without IBM's Hollerith machines the trains in Germany wouldn't have run on time, the Jews wouldn't have been so effectively herded into concentration camps, and the tallies of deaths and the specifics of slave labor wouldn't have been so efficiently compiled.  The Holocaust was undoubtedly accomplished with IBM collaboration, and if they managed not to see certain details of it it was only because they were too busy squeezing the Third Reich for its last pfennig.

What were the consequences of IBM's collaboration?  For the Jews, in countless cases, it was death.  For those serving the company in Germany the consequences were also death, sometimes imprisonment, and still other times relocation into IBM's new corporate hierarchy after the war.  The company as a whole prospered, and many of those directly responsible for IBM's actions in Germany escaped relatively unscathed.

It's a story that has been repeated many times.  We might even be seeing it now, with different actors, in the Russia-Ukraine conflict.  Company A, resident in Country A, wants to do business in Country B.  Yet at some point Country A and Country B go to war, and Company A has to decide how involved it wants to be in Country B's economy, and how much profit offsets how much risk.  Often Company A overextends itself, compromising its position to where tracks must be covered, and associations must be minimized.  

You also see this story repeated in China, wherein the designs of the Chinese Communist Party conflict with the expressed ideals of non-Chinese companies doing business there.

And the book?  Is it good?  Well, if you're asking me if it's entertaining I'd have to say no.  The corporate maneuvers detailed in this book make for excruciating reading, even if the author lays out a compelling case for IBM's dishonesty during World War II.  Did IBM create the Holocaust?  Certainly not, but they knew what was going on in Germany, and it couldn't have been accomplished on the same scale without their assistance.

Related Entries: